How to Choose Propellers for Mini Quad ?

This article explains the basics of propellers (props) for quadcopters. We go over the concepts of pitch, shape, difference in the number of blades and how these affect thrust, efficiency and performance. For a list of popular Mini Quad propellers, check out the mini quad parts list. Index of Content Propeller Size Effects of Prop Length and Pitch Surface Area Number of blades Direction of Rotation How to Read Propeller Spec Considerations in Choosing Mini Quad Props Thrust and Speed Knowing The Basics Size of Propellers Propellers exist in different length and pitch: The length of a propeller is the diameter of a disc the prop makes when it s spinning Pitch can be defined as the travel distance of one single prop rotation The larger the prop (either increasing diameter, or pitch or both), the more energy it takes to spin it. Effects of Prop Length and Pitch Propellers generate thrust by spinning and moving air. When the propeller is spun faster, the more air it can move, and thus the more thrust it generates. Fun fact, your multirotor won t fly in outer space, because there is no air and propellers won t generate any thrust :) By increasing either prop length or pitch, it gives more thrust and leads to higher current draw. Effectively it increases the surface area and drag, so more air can be moved and more power is required to spin it (assuming RPM is constant in this case). In a nutshell, larger propeller or higher pitch length will increase your aircraft s speed but also use more power. Generally speaking, a prop with smaller diameter or pitch can spin faster (higher RPM), because the motor doesn t need to work as hard to spin it so it pulls less current. They tend to run smoother and feels more responsive to the sticks. The faster change of RPM due to less inertia helps stability of the quadcopter. A higher pitch propeller moves greater amount of air, which might create turbulence and cause more prop wash. Props spin slower and you might find the lack of snappy feeling. But it generates more thrust and higher top speed in the expense of higher current draw. Surface Area and Shape Bullnose Props The more surface area, the more air the propeller can move and thus generate more thrust. But the downside is higher current draw, more drag and drop in power efficiency. The shape of a propeller plays a big role in performance because it s closely related to surface area. The most distinctive difference would probably be the tip of the props: pointy nose, bull nose (BN) and Hybrid bullnose (HBN). HBN has more surface area than pointy nose, while BN has even more surface area than the HBN. Pointy tip props are the most efficient of the three, however it pulls the least thrust. The other two props can give more power in the cost of more current draw. The shape of the tip also changes how the prop interacts with airflow when spinning, generally I found props with smooth/round edges perform more efficiently than blunt/square tip props. I have to say this is probably a personal experience, so please experiment with different styles to find your preference. Fun fact: You can create a bullnose prop by cutting the tip of a pointy nose prop :) For example, you can get a 5045BN by removing the tip of a 6045 normal prop with a pair of scissors. Number of Blades For mini quad pilots, 3-blade (or tri-blade) propellers are equally popular as the two blades, they are commonly used in both racing and free-style flying. Some people prefer triblades because it has more grip in the air. Basically, by adding more blade it s effectively adding more surface area, and therefore it generates more thrust in the expense of higher current draw and more drag. Propellers with even higher number of blades actually exist: quad-blade and even hex-blade! The quad blade are said to be great in indoor tracks, and perform well at cornering. But the increases in surface area makes them really inefficient, and much lower in RPM. And for the hexblade? I wouldn t even consider them at all, I think they make it for a joke :) simply too inefficient and draws way too much amps with any motors we have at the moment. Basically the more blades, the more inefficient it is. Two Different Prop Directions On every quadcopter, there are two motors spin CW (clockwise) and two CCW (counter-clockwise). Therefore matching CCW and CW propellers are required to generate thrust, as well as having opposing yaw motion that cancel each other out in flight. So when you buy props, make sure they come in pair, or grab both CW and CCW props if they are sold separately. I actually like the idea of buying props in only one direction, because I tend to break more CCW props for whatever reason :) (related to being right handed perhaps?) How to Read Spec There are 2 types of format that manufacturers use. L x P x B or LLPP x B L- length, P pitch, B number of blades. For example 6 4.5 (also known as 6045) propellers are 6 inch long and has a pitch of 4.5 inch. Another example, 5x4x3 (sometimes 5040 3) is a 3-blade 5 propeller that has a pitch of 4 inch. BN indicates Bullnose props. Sometimes you might see R or C after the size numbers, such as 5x3R. R indicates the rotation of the propeller, which stands for reversed . It should be mounted on a motor that spins clockwise. C is the opposite, should be used with motors that spins counter-clockwise. Considerations in Choosing Mini Quad Props Material Propellers can be made of different materials, plastic composite, carbon fibre, wood etc. Each type of material gives unique features, for example carbon fibre and wooden props are really stiff and best known for their smooth performance. While certain plastic compound are extremely durable. In fact, majority of the pilots in this hobby are now using what we call durable plastic props. They last much much longer and could save you tons of money in the long run. However, because they don t just snap in a crash, they bend. It s not obvious from appearance but they can cause vibration to your quadcopter, potentially giving your flight controller a hard time and leads to motor overheat. Make sure to make attention to vibration and oscillations when using these props. And don t use props with white crease lines . After a prop is bent it might develop these white lines and it s a sign of asking to be replaced. If you don t you risk snapping the propeller mid air and crashing. Weight Lighter props tend to perform better than heavier ones for mini quad in my experience, because there is less moment of inertia. RPM changes faster so the multirotor would feel more responsive in theory. Lighter props also run better on a wider range of motors, because they require less torque to spin up. Weight distribution of the blades also makes a difference. It again affects the moment of inertia. For the blade s center of mass closer to the hub is better for a propeller. Although that means the end of the prop gets thinner and easier to break. The more further away from the hub, the more drag there is and makes the prop harder to speed up and slow down. Rigidity The least rigid propeller I have ever used is the Gemfan 5030. They are so soft they literally bend when the motor reaches top RPM. Not only it will lose thrust and stability, it makes that crazy loud, high pitch noise! So rigidity is very important for a good prop. Rigidity is affected by the type of material and how much material is used. What To Use on Mini Quad? It depends on the size of your quad and your motors, mini quads normally use 4, 5 and 6 inch props. Roughly: 150-180mm 2700KV+ motor running 4 props 210mm 2300KV-2700KV motor running 5 props 250mm 1900KV-2300KV motor running 6 props To pick the right pitch, shape and number of blades, really depends on what sort of flying you want to do also. You also need to verify if the propeller hub size (hole in the center) fits your motor propeller shaft. Nearly all 4 , 5 and 6 propellers are designed for 5mm shafts. However, double check with any bigger or smaller props. Thrust and Speed It s important to look up motor thrust tests data, and see which props work best with the motor you plan to use. Same propeller can perform very differently on 2 different motors (because of the design, torque, power, etc). However these bench tests are done in static environment, and therefore it doesn t represent the motor/propellers true performance in real life where air are dynamic when the propellers are moving through the air. One of the most noticeable difference between static bench test and real flight is motor thrust, which is normally 5%-10% less in real flight than in static bench test. Also people like to talk about smoothness of a motor and propeller, which is not measurable quantitatively, and more of a pilot s feel. Another consideration is how propeller RPM affect your quadcopter s overall top speed. It s interesting to know that with a quad running heavy propellers that generate lots of thrust but at low RPM, is not necessary faster than one that generates less thrust but at a higher RPM. Your aircraft s theoretical speed can be calculated by Max Theoretical Speed = Max RPM * Propeller's Pitch * 60 However in reality your quad will be much slower than this due to many reasons such as air resistance, power reservation from PID controller etc. (Perhaps <50%) Conclusion As long as the motor/prop combo meets your amp draw requirement, you should try out as many props as you can to find the one that feelrdquo; right for what you do. Hope this post has helped you select the best motor and propellers, and don t hesitate to share your ideas or questions with us. :-) Source: https://oscarliang.com/choose-propellers-mini-quad/

Netz: Gens ace & Tattu Lipo Battery for RC Car FPV Heli UAV Drone - Gens Ace
Aktualisiert: 3.4.2024

zum Artikel gehen

How to Choose Propellers for Mini Quad ?

3 Zoll Quad (250g) mit DJI Air Unit 03

The New Released TBS Oblivion RTF Quadcopter

15 Things You Must Check Before Flying A FPV

Mini Tischtennisplatte

DJI Mini 3 Pro mit DJI RC Fernsteuerung für 799€ bei MediaMarkt